Carolina Shooters Forum banner

Traded a stolen gun

1.6K views 25 replies 8 participants last post by  michael52  
#1 · (Edited)
I guess it could happen to anyone so here is the story.

I had a Glock 35 and traded it to a guy for a sig 229 two tone. Since the Glock was on my books he filled out a 4473 and I have his purchase permit attached to it. It would seem that he may not have known it was stolen since he had no problem with filling out the paperwork.

I kept it for personal carry for about 6 months and then traded with a local guy for a 1911. He kept it for about 2 months and traded it at a local shop. He called me today and I met him to return the 1911. He gave me the paperwork he got from the shop with the case number and agency name.

Should I try to contact the guy I got it from and see if he will make it right?
 
#11 ·
The first one to say no is called Possession of Stolen Property. I could probably give the police an email address, phone number and name (or maybe alias) of who I got every one I own if it ever turned out to be stolen.
 
#14 ·
Isn't there a law about trafficking in stolen property? When you acquired it the first time you didn't know, but when you acquired it the second time you knowingly traded into a stolen item. This may be problematic, your good intentions notwithstanding.

In terms of trading backwards, what happens if the prior guy traded away already, then what do you trade for to "make it right." Seems complicated.

I would turn it in and take the financial hit, but I might talk to a lawyer first. I also wouldn't wait, last thing you want is for the sheriff to come looking.
 
#16 ·
A member on here contacted me once statin that a pistol he bought from me turned up as bein stolen. I called his bluff as it came from a pawn shop were all are searched for bein stolen.

I talked to the store manager and he made a few calls and basically said it was bs as none of his police contacts were able to turn up any information. He also had my contact information but never handed it over to the police officer that supposedly was on the case as I never received a call.

A few days later the store manager told me he had been contacted by the police he had called and they wanted to know if I wanted to pursue attempted fraud charges.

It was a bit nuts to say the least....but he said basically i was supposed to pay him then seek my money from the shop that sold it to me. He said this even though the shop he supposedly tried to sell it to paid him and kept the pistol. In the end I trusted the store manager that called the police while I stood by over someone that would not reply to me or my messages.

Not an easy call here...but I would wait until you could call and find out more info before choosing a course of action.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cowboysfan
#18 ·
I didn't get the gun back. The sheriff's dept here has taken the sig from the gun shop to be transported to Beaufort county. I am going to try and contact the person I got it from and hopefully he is a stand up guy.
 
#22 ·
How much real money did you have in the gun. If it's less than 500 bucks is it really worth going to court, I would call the guy and threaten him with a
Civil case but I wouldn't do it. You will probably loose that much in wages going after it not count just the aggravation.