In this thread I wanna talk about Bolt Carrier Groups.
The first thing I would like to discuss is the much debated/argued topic of "can you use an AUTO BCG in an AR15?"
I've read some on AR15.com, m4carbine.com, and few other sites where people go back and forth saying you can or can't. Each brings this or that from the ATF to try and validate their point. I think I understand that a heavier BCG (AUTO one) is more reliable and that's why most with AR15s want one (legality aside for the moment); is that true?
I found this on ATF's website:
http://www.atf.gov/publications/download/p/atf-p-5320-8/atf-p-5320-8-chapter-2.pdf
Section 2.1 Types of NFA firearms
The NFA defines the specific types of firearms subject to the provisions of the Act. These definitions
describe the function, design, configuration and/or dimensions that weapons must have to be NFA
firearms. In addition to describing the weapon, some definitions (machinegun, rifle, shotgun, any other
weapon) state that the firearm described also includes a weapon that can be readily restored to fire. A
firearm that can be readily restored to fire is a firearm that in its present condition is incapable of
expelling a projectile by the action of an explosive (or, in the case of a machinegun, will not in its
present condition shoot automatically) but which can be restored to a functional condition by the
replacement of missing or defective component parts. Please be aware that case law is not specific but
courts have held that the "readily restorable" test is satisfied where a firearm can be made capable of renewed automatic operation, even if it requires some degree of skill and the use of tools and parts.
It seems to ME that it is a very grey area on something that I'd rather have black and white. Obviously an AUTO BCG in an AR15 could be "readily restorible" for it to be full auto. I think I am gonna stay with a Semi auto BCG.
But this leads me to my next question. Why do 99% of the manufacturers only make AUTO BCGs if they are leaning toward the illegal side if put in an AR15??? Am I issing something here? Has the ATF made a ruling and not updated their site?
I've found a Bravo Company BCG for $150 but its an AUTO on BCM's site. They also have a LMT that's semi-auto for $130. What is a reasonable price for a quality BCG?
Let's discuss...
--DirtySCREW
The first thing I would like to discuss is the much debated/argued topic of "can you use an AUTO BCG in an AR15?"
I've read some on AR15.com, m4carbine.com, and few other sites where people go back and forth saying you can or can't. Each brings this or that from the ATF to try and validate their point. I think I understand that a heavier BCG (AUTO one) is more reliable and that's why most with AR15s want one (legality aside for the moment); is that true?
I found this on ATF's website:
http://www.atf.gov/publications/download/p/atf-p-5320-8/atf-p-5320-8-chapter-2.pdf
Section 2.1 Types of NFA firearms
The NFA defines the specific types of firearms subject to the provisions of the Act. These definitions
describe the function, design, configuration and/or dimensions that weapons must have to be NFA
firearms. In addition to describing the weapon, some definitions (machinegun, rifle, shotgun, any other
weapon) state that the firearm described also includes a weapon that can be readily restored to fire. A
firearm that can be readily restored to fire is a firearm that in its present condition is incapable of
expelling a projectile by the action of an explosive (or, in the case of a machinegun, will not in its
present condition shoot automatically) but which can be restored to a functional condition by the
replacement of missing or defective component parts. Please be aware that case law is not specific but
courts have held that the "readily restorable" test is satisfied where a firearm can be made capable of renewed automatic operation, even if it requires some degree of skill and the use of tools and parts.
It seems to ME that it is a very grey area on something that I'd rather have black and white. Obviously an AUTO BCG in an AR15 could be "readily restorible" for it to be full auto. I think I am gonna stay with a Semi auto BCG.
But this leads me to my next question. Why do 99% of the manufacturers only make AUTO BCGs if they are leaning toward the illegal side if put in an AR15??? Am I issing something here? Has the ATF made a ruling and not updated their site?
I've found a Bravo Company BCG for $150 but its an AUTO on BCM's site. They also have a LMT that's semi-auto for $130. What is a reasonable price for a quality BCG?
Let's discuss...
--DirtySCREW
