Those two are like Coke/Pepsi really.


I prefer Mossberg, the safety is in a better location for me, and it just feels better overall.

When comparing the two you need to compare similar models. Comparing a 870 police model to a run of the mill, maverick is not a fair comparison.

 

Nothing about the Mossberg sacrifices quality over an 870.

 

I own both and the 870 feels better and handles better in my opinion. But the Mossy is a solid shotgun also and both get the Job done.

 

Mossberg thunder ranch is a nice option! Picked one up from a buddy and it is a very solid thunder stick.

 

I also chose the Mossberg for the safety location.

 

I prefer the Remington because it's lots better. Just like .45 is better than 9mm, and 1911's are better than Glocks.

Actually, that Pepsi vs. Coke comment is about right on. Different folks like the very slight differences. I wouldn't expect either would ever let you down.

 

The 870 tactical is great. There are 3 different shops around here that have them 375-400 bucks.

 

If you are left handed an Ithica 37 is a good option as well. Solid gun, and bottom ejecting.

 

I also chose the Mossberg for the safety location.

And the slide release location. That forward of the trigger guard release on the 870 is assinine design.

If you want a good tactical 870 shotgun, buy the H&R Pardner pump protect. It's a better modern 870 than anything coming out of Ilion NY nowadays. Cheaper to boot.

 

I'm an 870 guy thought and through, I've always had one since i was about 17 years old. If you go mossy, get a 590A1, they are overbuilt to the point of even having dual shell extractors. The main thing i notice between the 2 is the safety location and you have to surf out the shell if you want to do a slug changeover on a mossberg loosing 2 rounds as opposed to 1 in the remington. Whatever you get, learn to run it and it won't let you down.

 

Mossberg hands down

 

Love my Mossy. Wouldn't give it up. Handles good and shoots good. What more could you ask for?

 

I'm an 870 guy thought and through, I've always had one since i was about 17 years old. If you go mossy, get a 590A1, they are overbuilt to the point of even having dual shell extractors. The main thing i notice between the 2 is the safety location and you have to surf out the shell if you want to do a slug changeover on a mossberg loosing 2 rounds as opposed to 1 in the remington. Whatever you get, learn to run it and it won't let you down.

All current production Mossberg 500s and Maverick 88s have dual shell extractors. The 590s main claim to fame is a thicker barrel, 8-round mag tube setup, and a heat shield.

 

I asked myself the same question as the OP.... ended up with 870 Taticool

 

I have owned both a 870 and a 500 at the same time. I now have just 2 870's. Mossberg makes great guns. I just like the rems better. Mossberg makes great guns. Get the one that feels best.

Dale

 

Mossberg, the Remingtons are over priced and not built like they where 20 years ago, they also rust very easily. The only real advantage the remington has over the mossberg 500 is the ability to expand the mag capacity with screw on tubes. If you buy a hi cap mossberg to start with it is not a issue. The 590 is awesome if you want to go all out.

 

All current production Mossberg 500s and Maverick 88s have dual shell extractors. The 590s main claim to fame is a thicker barrel, 8-round mag tube setup, and a heat shield.

And if you get the A1 model a bayonet lug.

 

Mossberg, the Remingtons are over priced and not built like they where 20 years ago, they also rust very easily.

Never had an issue with that on my mossy. But then again I give it a light oil wipe down after cleaning/handling.

 

x

 

I also chose the Mossberg for the safety location.

And me

 

Can't say anything about the Mossberg.

My gunsmith told me the 870 Express is cheap for a reason. Doesn't have the same quality of parts as the Wingmaster.

 

Grew up with an 870 - and carried one at work for alot of years.
They just get slicker and smoother with age. Have also had Mossbergs that did well.

My current favorite is a Rem. M870 Marine Magnum that's slick as can be.

 

Did someone say Marine edition? Top is a 20" Mossberg 590 with Marine Coat. Bottom is an 18.5" Stainless steel Mossberg 500 with heat shield.

Had several 870s and obviously a few Mossbergs. Never had an issue with either but I like the Mossbergs better because of safety placement. Also I am more likely to short stroke with an 870 but that's probably just me. 870 seems to have more of an aftermarket.

 

Can't say anything about the Mossberg.

My gunsmith told me the 870 Express is cheap for a reason. Doesn't have the same quality of parts as the Wingmaster.

+1 on the Wingmaster vs Express. A older Wingmaster even more so.

Mine is a ISP (Indiana State Patrol), top folder, 2 3/4", trade in that I guess is from the early 80's. IDK, it was from a SGN ad in the late 80's, early 90's.

Nice, but getting older I'd like something with a real stock and lighter. The 870, 20ga, Deer special (20" bbl, rifle sights), is looking good, but scarce+not cheap. The PG on mine is getting less and less appealing as I get older and the folding (metal) stock is only good for bracing against your hip.

Wet

 

Don't be afraid of the Stevens 350. I just bought the combo security/field, it's a great gun for $300.